I was once told by a manager that they preferred staff on short-term contracts because it kept them “hungry”, “keen” and stopped them becoming “complacent”.
It never sat comfortably with me. I could see how uncertainty might keep someone busy. I was less convinced that worrying about their future was a particularly enlightened approach to managing them.
So, when I saw the headline suggesting researchers need to learn to say no to projects, my first thought was: fair enough. My second was: what happens to the person who does?
There is a difference between knowing you have too much work and feeling able to turn some of it down.

A sensible suggestion, with a few complications
The recent Times Higher Education article reports a discussion about choosing research projects strategically and giving them the relationships and support needed to influence policy. It also acknowledges that university measures of success can pull researchers in different directions. That is a reasonable discussion to have, and it deserves more than an irritated response to the headline. [1]
There is a good case for doing fewer things properly. Research needs time to think, read, analyse and occasionally discover that your original idea was wrong. None of this becomes easier when every spare hour has acquired another commitment.
But deciding which projects an institution should support is a different exercise from deciding which opportunities you can afford to decline when your own employment has an expiry date.
I spent five years on six-month contracts before securing my fellowship. That made buying a house and planning my future difficult. I was employed, and grateful to be employed, but the uncertainty was still there.
In those circumstances, another collaboration or funding application can look like a possible route to continued employment. Saying yes may be a calculated response to insecurity. Teaching someone to decline more politely does not change the calculation.
What does the research tell us?
We need to be careful here. A fixed-term contract, a precarious job and a fear of losing employment are related, but they are not interchangeable.
A well-supported, time-limited role with a clear purpose may be a useful opportunity. Equally, someone with a permanent contract may feel profoundly insecure during restructuring. The date printed on the contract tells us something, but it does not tell us everything.
Rönnblad and colleagues’ 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies found moderate-quality evidence linking job insecurity with poorer mental health. The pooled odds ratio was 1.52, with a 95% confidence interval of 1.35–1.70. However, they rated the evidence concerning temporary employment itself as very low quality. [2]
That distinction matters. The finding supports concern about insecurity; it does not mean that every fixed-term contract causes harm, or that researchers on such contracts have a 52% greater probability of developing a mental health condition. Odds and probabilities are different, and these studies covered working populations beyond academia.
Research focused on academics adds detail to that picture. Nicholls and colleagues’ 2022 systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis brought together 26 papers. It identified job insecurity, high expectations and financial pressures as important features of researchers’ accounts of poor mental health and wellbeing. Supportive relationships, mentoring and opportunities for progression also mattered. [3]
Qualitative evidence helps explain how these pressures are experienced. It cannot give us a single causal estimate of the effect of a six-month contract, but it can show why uncertainty about work becomes uncertainty about life.

The evidence deserves an argument, not a victory lap
There is also evidence that complicates a straightforward story about temporary employment damaging health.
Dawson and colleagues analysed British Household Panel Survey data, covering around 8,000 people. They found that permanent employees who subsequently moved into temporary employment already had poorer mental health than those who remained permanently employed. Job dissatisfaction helped explain that relationship. [4]
Their findings suggest that some comparisons between temporary and permanent workers may overestimate the effect of contract type because health differences precede the move. This was not a study of academic researchers specifically, but it is a useful reminder to be cautious about the direction of an association.
Universities also face practical constraints. A project may have a defined endpoint, and funding may only cover a particular period. Some researchers actively want a temporary opportunity to develop a skill, change direction or work with a particular team.
Those are credible reasons for time-limited employment. They do not settle whether repeated short renewals are necessary, how early decisions should be communicated, or who should carry the uncertainty between grants.
My concern is with treating that uncertainty as a management advantage. If keeping people worried is expected to keep them productive, we should examine the costs as carefully as the output.
Where occupational health comes in
An occupational health perspective asks about workload, control, support and the organisation of work. It also asks whether the conditions encouraging someone to overcommit can be changed.
The HSE’s Management Standards expect work demands to be achievable within agreed working hours and concerns about those demands to be addressed. A calendar does not acquire extra capacity because the next request is described as an exciting opportunity. [5]
In a 2023 qualitative study involving 26 UK academic researchers, Nicholls and colleagues identified the need to address job insecurity and unrealistic workloads alongside improving support. Managers and supervisors were central to participants’ experiences of their working environment. [6]
That has practical implications. If a researcher is asked to take on something new, there should be a conversation about what moves, stops or receives additional help. If a contract is approaching its end, clear and timely communication should be a priority, including honesty about what remains undecided.
We should also consider what declining work means for the person being asked. Someone who depends on a senior colleague for a reference, access to funding or their next post may hear an “optional” invitation rather differently.

Learning to say no, and learning to hear it
There is personal responsibility here too. Interesting research is interesting. Helping colleagues matters. Sometimes we accept work because we care about it, enjoy it or underestimate how long it will take. A good idea can be very persuasive when it has not yet introduced you to its administration.
Learning to pause before agreeing is useful. So is being realistic about what we can deliver. Overcommitting can let down collaborators, students and ourselves.
But advice about boundaries needs to be accompanied by working conditions that allow people to maintain them. Managers need the resources and authority to support those decisions. Funders and institutions need to consider how employment arrangements shape the behaviour they then ask researchers to change.
I do not think every fixed-term contract is unreasonable, or every additional project should be declined. I do think we should be wary of calling insecurity motivation, and of treating a predictable response to it as an individual failure.
Researchers can learn to say no. The more revealing question may be what their workplace does with the answer.
What would universities and funders need to change for declining additional work to become a realistic choice for researchers whose next contract is still uncertain?
References
1. Skillen, R. (2026). Researchers ‘need to learn how to say no to projects’. Times Higher Education, 18 November.
2. Rönnblad, T. et al. (2019). Precarious employment and mental health: a systematic review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 45(5), 429–443. doi:10.5271/sjweh.3797.
3. Nicholls, H., Nicholls, M., Tekin, S., Lamb, D. and Billings, J. (2022). The impact of working in academia on researchers’ mental health and well-being: A systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis. PLOS ONE, 17(5), e0268890. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0268890.
4. Dawson, C., Veliziotis, M., Pacheco, G. and Webber, D.J. (2015). Is temporary employment a cause or consequence of poor mental health? A panel data analysis. Social Science & Medicine, 134, 50–58. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.04.001.
5. Health and Safety Executive. Management Standards: Demands.
6. Nicholls, H., Lamb, D., Johnson, S., Higgs, P., Pinfold, V. and Billings, J. (2023). “Fix the system … the people who are in it are not the ones that are broken”: A qualitative study exploring UK academic researchers’ views on support at work. Heliyon, 9(10), e20454. doi:10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e20454.
Illustrations created with AI for this article; they depict fictional scenes.

Leave a Reply